Comparative Analysis of Financing Efficiency between State-Owned and Private Enterprises in PPPProjects

doi:10.12005/orms.2022.0203

Abstract

Abstract: Nowadays, PPP (public-private partnerships) schemes have been applied worldwide, but the financing efficiency of investors is generally low. That doesseriously undermine the performance and restrict the sustainable development of PPP schemes. Based on 51 listed state-owned and private enterprises in PPP projects, this paper illustrates the comparative analysis of financing efficiency between the two different enterprise typesfrom the perspective of three project types and two regions using DEA model. The results show that main business cost and equity concentration are staple factors for low efficiency in PPP projects, and the low return on net assets is one of the main reasons for investorsnot unwilling to actively participate in PPP projects. For state-owned enterprises, optimizing the scale efficiency of PPP projects is the key to improving financing efficiency, while for private enterprises, reasonable shareholding structure plays an important role in the internal performance and investment strategy. Private enterprises should focus on optimizing and reducing the debt ratio, and rationally and equitably distribute equity. Thus, enterprises with scale efficiency and pure technical efficiency can participate in PPP projects through the formation of consortiums so as to complement each other's advantages, thereby improving the overall efficiency of the project company. Furthermore, in view of the characteristics of PPP projects in different fields and regions, it is necessary to give full play of the state-owned enterprises with strong capital strength and the private enterprises with technical advantages when purchasing investors, providing a reference for the improvement of the financing efficiency and helping the sustainable development of PPP schemes.

Key words: PPP projects, financing efficiency, state-owned enterprises, private enterprises, DEA model

摘要： 目前PPP模式的应用范围不断扩大,但投资者的融资效率普遍不高。投资者融资效率低下严重影响PPP项目绩效,制约PPP模式的可持续发展。本文以51家主营业务为PPP项目的国有企业与民营企业为样本,运用DEA模型分别从整体、不同领域和不同地区之间对比分析双方融资效率的异同。结果显示参与PPP项目投资者的规模效率普遍不足,主营成本与股权集中度是导致融资效率低下的主要因素,净资产收益率较低则是投资者不愿积极参与PPP项目的一个主要原因。对国企而言,优化企业对PPP项目的规模效率是提高融资效率的关键;而民企应注重优化和降低资产负债率,合理均衡地分配股权。因此,建议具有规模效率和纯技术效率优势的投资者通过组建联合体等方式参与PPP项目,实现优势互补,从而提高项目公司的整体效率。此外,也要针对不同领域和不同地区PPP项目的特点和对投资者的要求,有针对性地选择投资者,充分发挥国企资金实力雄厚和民企专业技术的优势,提高融资效率,助力PPP实践的可持续发展。

关键词: PPP项目, 融资效率, 国有企业, 民营企业, DEA模型

CLC Number:

F283

GAO Ruo-lan, HU Jia, LIU Ji-cai. Comparative Analysis of Financing Efficiency between State-Owned and Private Enterprises in PPPProjects[J]. Operations Research and Management Science, 2022, 31(6): 204-210.

高若兰, 胡嘉, 刘继才. PPP项目中国有企业与民营企业的融资效率对比研究[J]. 运筹与管理, 2022, 31(6): 204-210.

References

[1] 高颖,张水波,冯卓.PPP项目运营期间需求量下降情形下的补偿机制研究[J].管理工程学报,2015,29(2):93-102.
[2] 王颖林,刘继才,赖芨宇.基于投资方投机行为的PPP项目激励机制博弈研究[J].管理工程学报,2016,30(2):223-232.
[3] 景诗龙,王俊豪.基于动力机制的中国PPP模式发展策略研究[J].经济与管理研究,2018,39(4):136-144.
[4] Hueskes M, Koen V, Thomas B. Governing public-private partnerships for sustainability: an analysis of procurement and governance practices of PPP infrastructure projects[J]. International Journal of Project Management, 2017, 35(6): 1184-1195.
[5] 李宗荣.政府投资效率与PPP融资模式研究[J].财会学习,2017(24):235.
[6] 周正祥.新常态下PPP模式应用存在的问题及对策[J].中国软科学,2015(9):82-95.
[7] 张禄,石磊,戴大双,马力.PPP项目政府担保对项目效率影响研究[J].中国管理科学,2017,25(8):89-102.
[8] Wang X, Zhang Y, Zhang Y, Xiao, Y. Enhancing financing efficiency of international PPP projects: a case study of multi-national gas pipeline project[J]. International Journal of Architecture, Engineering and Construction, 2016, 5: 175-184.
[9] Shi L, He Y, Onishi M, Kobayashi K. Efficiency analysis of government subsidy and performance guarantee policies in relation to PPP infrastructure projects[J]. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2018(2): 1-11.
[10] 查云璐,李博,高廷璧.PPP项目股权融资效率评价——基于DEA模型的分析[J].金融会计,2017(6):61-72.
[11] Qiu Y, Akram U, Lin S, Nazam M. How to predict financing efficiency in public-private partnerships-in an aspect of uncertainties[C]//International Conference on Management Science and Engineering Management. Springer, Cham, 2017: 247-259.
[12] 汤薇,吴海龙.基于政府角度的PPP项目融资效益研究——以BOT与BOO模式为例[J].科研管理,2014,35(1):157-162.
[13] Cleal P, Porter A. PFI financing comes of age[J]. Public Private Finance, 2004(79): 18.
[14] 杨德权,杜冰竹.基于关联网络DEA的供应链协调程度评价[J].运筹与管理,2018,27(9):51-56.
[15] Liu J, Zhu J, Zhang J. A DEA-based approach for competitive environment analysis in global operations strategies[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2018, 203: 110-123.
[16] 张晓明,王应明,施海柳.效率视角下创新型企业关键资源优化配置研究[J].科研管理,2018,39(5):103-111.
[17] 刘满凤,李圣宏.基于三阶段DEA模型的我国高新技术开发区创新效率研究[J].管理评论,2016,28(01):42-52,155.
[18] Khan M K, He Y, Akram U, Sarwar S. Financing and monitoring in an emerging economy: can investment efficiency be increased?[J]. China Economic Review, 2017, 45: 62-77.
[19] Wang T S, Lin Y M, Werner E M, Chang H. The relationship between external financing activities and earnings management: evidence from enterprise risk management[J]. International Review of Economics & Finance, 2018, 58: 312-329.
[20] 黄辉.企业特征、融资方式与企业融资效率[J].预测,2009,28(2):21-27.
[21] Demirag I, Dubnick M, Khadaroo M I. A framework for examining accountability and value for money in the UK's private fFinance initiative[J]. Journal of Corporate Citizenship, 2004(15): 63-76.
[22] Andreasen E, Valenzuela P. Financial openness, domestic financial development and credit ratings[J]. Finance Research Letters, 2016, 16: 11-18.
[23] Shen L Y, Platten A, Deng X P. Role of public private partnerships to manage risks in public sector projects in Hong Kong[J]. International Journal of Project Management, 2006, 24(7): 587-594.
[24] 林宇,邱煜,高清平.基于三阶段DEA的房地产公司债务融资效率研究[J].科研管理,2013,34(8):147-157.
[25] 刘超,傅若瑜,李佳慧,周文文.基于DEA-Tobit方法的人工智能行业上市公司融资效率研究[J].运筹与管理,2019,28(6):144-152.
[26] 王秀贞,丁慧平,胡毅.基于DEA方法的我国中小企业融资效率评价[J].系统工程理论与实践,2017,37(4):865-874.
[27] 刘力昌,冯根福,张道宏,毛红霞.基于DEA的上市公司股权融资效率评价[J].系统工程,2004(1):55-59.
[28] 宫兴国,孙新明.基于两阶段DEA模型的物流企业融资效率研究——以31家物流上市公司为例[J].会计之友,2017(5):103-107.
[29] Liu J, Gao R, Cheah C Y J, Luo, J. Evolutionary game of investors' opportunistic behaviour during the operational period in PPP projects[J]. Construction Management and Economics, 2017, 35(3): 137-153.
[30] Sánchez J F M, Lechuga G P. Assessment of a credit scoring system for popular bank savings and credit[J]. Contaduría y Administración, 2016, 61(2): 391-417.